Rough Cut Reviews

David Metcalfe’s departure from Emmerdale marked the end of an era for fans of the long-running ITV soap. Played by Matthew Wolfenden for nearly two decades, David’s exit was confirmed a few months ago, and this week it was revealed within the storyline that he will not be returning to the village.

Viewers were reminded of David’s absence during a recent episode, where his family learned that he had chosen not to come back. This followed the emotional scenes that aired when David originally left the show, coinciding with Matthew Wolfenden’s decision to step away from the role.

At the time of his departure, speculation circulated that David might be written out permanently. One source close to the production hinted that the character could be killed off, suggesting that Wolfenden was ready for a new challenge after a period of limited dramatic storylines. “He’s a fan favourite,” the source noted, “so he’ll be supported in whatever comes next. There’s real excitement about what opportunities lie ahead.”

However, fans were relieved to discover that David’s departure didn’t involve a fatal storyline. Instead, he left the village to reunite with his ex-partner Priya and their daughter Amba. His decision came after he discovered that his son Jacob had fallen in love with Victoria, David’s former partner. Struggling to come to terms with their relationship, David felt he had no option but to leave. The news was met with heartbreak by Jacob and Eric Pollard, who were left reeling from his sudden exit.

Is David Metcalfe Gone for Good?

Matthew Wolfenden has addressed the question many fans have been asking: is this truly the end for David Metcalfe? Speaking candidly, the actor admitted that leaving was a daunting decision.

“I’m really nervous about leaving after almost twenty years,” he said. “But it feels like the right time. I’ve been told the door is open—they’re not killing me off. That’s something I can share. So, who knows? I might return one day.”

Wolfenden also reflected on how the show shaped his life beyond the screen. “I met my wife on Emmerdale, we’ve had three kids. It hasn’t just been 18 years of work—it’s given me my family. Leaving it behind is a huge change, no question.”

As for how the story played out on screen, the actor hinted that Victoria played a significant role in David’s departure. “There is a sort of resolution,” he said, careful not to reveal too much. “Let’s just say Victoria is the reason he leaves the village.”

This was confirmed during the dramatic reveal when David accidentally uncovered the secret romance between Jacob and Victoria. Unable to bear the emotional fallout, he made the painful decision to walk away from his life in the Dales.

While David’s future in Emmerdale remains uncertain, the character has been written out in a way that leaves the possibility open for a return. For now, fans are left to say goodbye to one of the show’s most enduring figures—at least for the time being.